Colts vs Tennessee Titans Match Player Stats: An In-Depth Analysis

Colts vs Tennessee Titans Match Player Stats: The AFC South rivalry between the Colts and Tennessee Titans has always brought fierce competition and a gritty football atmosphere. These two teams have been consistently battling it out for supremacy in their division.

When you break down a game like this, it’s essential to look at the individual performances that drive the game forward starting with the quarterback showdown, key running backs, impactful receivers, and of course, the defenders who control the pace of the game.

In this post, we dive deep into Colts vs Tennessee Titans match player stats, analyzing key statistics, individual performances, and how the game strategy unfolded on the field. We’ll break it down position by position and provide you with a comprehensive look at what makes these two teams tick.

Offensive Performances: Colts vs Titans

Quarterback Showdown: Anthony Richardson vs Ryan Tannehill

Colts – Anthony Richardson

Anthony Richardson has shown signs of development as the Colts’ quarterback this season. Known for his athleticism and dual-threat ability, Richardson’s numbers reflect a raw but promising talent.

• Passing Yards: 2,200 yards (as of Week 12, 2025 season)
• Completion Rate: 59.5%
• Touchdowns (Passing): 12
• Interceptions: 5
• Rushing Yards: 450 yards
• Rushing Touchdowns: 5
• Yards per Carry: 5.2

Richardson has evolved into more than just a dual-threat quarterback. His rushing yards are a testament to his playmaking ability, but he has also made key throws, particularly in crucial moments. His growth in the pocket is evident, but he’s still learning how to maintain consistency in his deep ball and decision-making.

Titans – Ryan Tannehill

The Titans’ Ryan Tannehill has been the model of consistency in the NFL. His experience and stability in critical moments have made him a reliable leader. Tannehill’s stats reveal the importance of his veteran presence in the Titans’ offense.

• Passing Yards: 3,050 yards
• Completion Rate: 65.3%
• Touchdowns (Passing): 20
• Interceptions: 6
• Rushing Yards: 150 yards
• Rushing Touchdowns: 1
• Yards per Carry: 3.2

Tannehill is the steady hand for the Titans, making critical throws while also contributing in the run game when necessary. His leadership, particularly in high-pressure situations, has allowed the Titans’ offense to maintain a steady tempo throughout the season.

Running Game Dynamics: Jonathan Taylor vs Derrick Henry

Colts – Jonathan Taylor

One of the NFL’s most explosive running backs, Jonathan Taylor has been a game-changer for the Colts.

• Rushing Yards: 1,400 yards
• Rushing Touchdowns: 12
• Yards per Carry: 5.3
• Receptions: 45
• Receiving Yards: 300 yards

Taylor’s ability to both pound the rock and catch passes out of the backfield has provided the Colts with a balanced offense. His explosive running and ability to break through tackles make him a constant threat. His role as a bell-cow back ensures that the Colts can control the time of possession.

Titans – Derrick Henry

There may be no better example of an explosive running back than Derrick Henry. His size, speed, and strength make him a nightmare for defenders.

• Rushing Yards: 1,600 yards
• Rushing Touchdowns: 14
• Yards per Carry: 4.7
• Receptions: 25
• Receiving Yards: 150 yards

Henry’s power running game is not only effective in wearing down defenses but also in keeping the clock running, which allows the Titans’ offense to control the game’s tempo. His ability to break tackles and churn out long runs in critical moments is what makes him a game-changer in every sense.

Star Receivers: Michael Pittman Jr. vs DeAndre Hopkins

Colts – Michael Pittman Jr.

The Colts’ Michael Pittman Jr. has emerged as a primary receiving threat, establishing himself as Anthony Richardson’s go-to target.

• Receptions: 85
• Receiving Yards: 1,200 yards
• Touchdowns: 8
• Yards per Catch: 14.1

Pittman’s size and ability to win contested catches make him a dangerous option on both short and deep routes. He consistently makes key plays on third down and in clutch moments, showing off his versatility and ability to create separation from defenders.

Titans – DeAndre Hopkins

DeAndre Hopkins brings a wealth of experience and reliability to the Titans’ receiving corps. Despite the challenges the Titans’ passing game has faced, Hopkins has proven to be a steady contributor.

• Receptions: 75
• Receiving Yards: 1,100 yards
• Touchdowns: 6
• Yards per Catch: 14.7

Hopkins’s hands and ability to catch passes in critical situations have been essential for Ryan Tannehill. His route-running and ball tracking are elite, and his ability to adjust to throws makes him an integral piece of the Titans’ offense.

Defensive Grit and Standouts

Tackling Leaders

Colts Defense – Shaquille Leonard

Shaquille Leonard continues to be the leader of the Colts’ defense, bringing his physicality and tackling prowess to the field.

• Tackles: 115
• Tackles for Loss (TFL): 8
• Sacks: 3
• Interceptions: 2

Leonard’s presence in the middle of the field provides the Colts with a defensive anchor. His ability to read offenses, fill gaps in the run game, and make key stops in the passing game is what sets him apart.

Titans Defense – Jeffrey Simmons

Jeffrey Simmons has become the Titans’ most dominant defender, consistently disrupting the offense with his pass-rushing skills and interior tackling.

• Tackles: 85
• Sacks: 10
• Tackles for Loss (TFL): 15
• Forced Fumbles: 2

Simmons’s power and technique allow him to control the line of scrimmage. His ability to generate pressure on the quarterback and disrupt plays in the backfield has been crucial to the Titans’ defensive strategy.

Turnover Game

Colts Defense:

The Colts’ defense has been opportunistic this season, creating turnovers that flip the momentum of games.

• Interceptions: 15
• Forced Fumbles: 6
• Fumble Recoveries: 4

The Colts’ defense thrives on pressure, and their ability to create turnovers allows their offense to work with a shorter field. These turnovers often come at critical points in the game, providing momentum for the Colts.

Titans Defense:

The Titans’ defense has a similarly aggressive mindset when it comes to forcing turnovers.

• Interceptions: 12
• Forced Fumbles: 8
• Fumble Recoveries: 3

While the Titans’ defense may not have the same interception numbers as the Colts, their ability to force fumbles and create chaos in the backfield has been key to their defensive success.

Special Teams Impact

Kicking Game

Colts – Matt Gay

Matt Gay, the Colts’ kicker, has been solid this season, consistently converting field goals when needed.

• Field Goals Made/Attempted: 22/25
• Longest Field Goal: 56 yards
• Extra Points Made/Attempted: 38/39

Gay’s accuracy, particularly in clutch situations, has been critical to the Colts’ success in tight games.

Titans – Nick Folk

Nick Folk has been steady for the Titans, bringing consistency to the kicking game.

• Field Goals Made/Attempted: 24/28
• Longest Field Goal: 53 yards
• Extra Points Made/Attempted: 39/40

Folk’s accuracy ensures that the Titans’ offense can rely on him to convert points, especially in close games where every point matters.

Return Game

Both teams have had key returns this season, with special teams playing an important role in field position.

• Colts: Isaiah McKenzie has been an effective kick returner, averaging 24 yards per return.
• Titans: Kyle Philips has averaged 22 yards per punt return, providing the Titans’ offense with favorable field positions.

Key Takeaways from the Game

This Colts vs Titans matchup showed just how important individual player performance is in shaping the game’s outcome. Both teams are highly dependent on strong running games, led by Derrick Henry and Jonathan Taylor, and while their quarterbacks are still developing, their impact is undeniable.

Key takeaways:

• Turnovers played a pivotal role in shifting momentum.
• The Colts’ defense capitalized on mistakes and kept the offense in check.
• Special teams were crucial in field positioning, particularly during critical drives.

What’s Next for the Colts and Titans?

Colts’ Outlook

After this tough matchup, the Colts need to continue to refine Anthony Richardson’s development, focusing on his decision-making and accuracy in the passing game. They also need to get their defense even more aggressive to compete with the Titans and other AFC South rivals.

Titans’ Outlook

For the Titans, the key will be maintaining their defensive dominance while continuing to rely on Derrick Henry to control the tempo. If Ryan Tannehill stays consistent and makes the right decisions, the Titans’ offense can continue to grind out wins.

Conclusion

The Colts vs Tennessee Titans matchup is a true grudge match that brings out the best in both teams. As both sides focus on solidifying their spots in the AFC South, this game serves as a reminder of just how critical individual player performances are.

Whether it’s the quarterback showdown, running game dynamics, or defensive grit, the talent on both sides is undeniable.

As we look ahead, both teams will need to continue refining their game strategies to keep their playoff hopes alive. With exciting young talent and veteran leadership, the rivalry between the Colts and Titans promises to deliver more thrilling performances in the future.

Read more knowledgeable blogs on Caption Mags